Brooklyn Hermeneutic Association
by David H. Rommereim One of my deepest regrets is loss of play. Play provides the enthusiasm, laughter, and serious work for the things that may either harm or heal the soul. Play is the force that reconciles our fears and worries while developing courage. Have you ever watched a child 3 years or under play? They are working so hard, diligently, and carefully to make sure they know what and how to make things work. They don't whine if they make a mistake. They don't blame, or shame anything or anyone. They just work hard at play. Then to help them "grow up" we begin to train them differently. Not by teaching right and wrong through adventure, play, and the joy of learning, but the zero sum game of being on the right side. The photo above is one of my favorites. I took it at one of our first Children, Youth, and Family ministry gatherings. It was from a class I was teaching about Baptism. I am fully aware that children and adults learn by the poetic exchange of sound, words, touch, and physical exchange. At the lesson, I had the kids dig into the font at the front of the sanctuary. We then met at Baptism. They dug into the font swishing the water and giggling. I believe that the only way to be a Christian is to be happy. What sort of God do you listen to if you are not filled with the joy and hospitality of grace, forgiveness, and love. Each is God's spiritual and religious nutrient provided for us through the story of Yeshua of Nazareth. Remember, he was a Jewish poet/prophet we later named Jesus, the Christ of God. My goal for the ministry of Children, Youth, and Families at Good Shepherd was to turn the Soul Cafe into a living space for children. It was to be safe, honorable, respectful, and inter-generational. Most of the present members at Good Shepherd do not know that the Soul Cafe was not always the soul cafe. It was called "the transept?" and it was a dark, dreary, dusty, smelly large room with row upon row, wall to wall, pews in a space that needed a flashlight to move from one corner to another. We renovated it to create the Soul Cafe (a name which took three years to change). It became the soul cafe by practice, practice, practice. We used the Soul Cafe so that our neighbors could enjoy a safe place in which to work through tough cultural/political/community issues. It was also designed for our children to be welcomed to church in a joyous spirit. Change was hard but God persisted. I knew the Soul Cafe was becoming safe for kids when I saw many of them come in after a hard day at school, kick off their shoes, jackets, and heavy backpacks, then run and play together. Some of the older adults were not used to seeing that sort of play so close to the sanctuary. They thought that the kids may do something wrong. We had a lot of worry about play. What if they upset an older member. However, I remained faithful to the Gospel by sharing that to understand the experience of Baptism we need to dig our hands into the font of welcome; get a little wet. 1 Timothy 1.7 reminds us about what it is like if you are timid, and it's not good. None of the children in the photo above are at Good Shepherd today. Their families have moved on. At the congregation festival of ministry on June 29, 2014, we welcomed over 23 kids and honored 22 adults who worked in some way in education (teachers, administrators, adjunct professors, etc.). Each one was named and counted in our ministry at Good Shepherd. Some are among us weekly. Some are among us a few times a year. Some are among us rarely. Each is an abiding resemblance of God's love and God's Baptism. Not one was better than the other. All were equal under God's canopy of Grace. I have read an amazing book about some of the things our children are losing. Specifically, the courage of learning through play and imagination. Jay Griffiths is a writer from Wales, Britain. She reminds us that our children and adult community are experiencing the loss of adventure. She calls it the loss of "The Commons." The Commons is the place where individuals safely adventure, walk, and experiment. It is where learning happens in the most humane form, "The fun of learning." The book is called, 'Kith: The Riddle of the Childscape.' Ms. Griffiths' riddle has to do with the loss of the commons where children can no longer play freely. I do not mean organized dance groups or sports. I am not referring to Sunday morning schedules which keep you from sacred sabbath time. I don't refer to the structures we build for families that let kids "go out and play." I used to take my children to those places while living in the South Bronx where we had 1.6 acres of park land developed for 150,000 residents in that part of the Bronx. We would drive into Westchester County and knew all the formal playgrounds developed during the 80s. By play and commons, I am not referring to the designed tunnels, ladders, or swings. I refer to the loss of free play. And I believe the ministry of the church must maintain that sense of free play before we get too smart for our britches and produce clones, or ventriloquists, rather than courageous theologians. The loss of the commons and the loss of a place to freely play, forces the child to stave off imagination, develop less courage, and garner more fear. Jay Griffiths writes that in England kids would always climb trees. That was true for me growing up. I climbed trees a lot.[1] In her book, Ms. Griffiths informs us that in England there were over 2,500 kids per year who were hurt from falling out of trees. So they made a law about climbing trees. It said: "No Tree Climbing Allowed!" However, she then reminded us that, at the same time there were over 3,000 kids hurt by falling out of bed. She wondered whether they should make a law, "No Getting Into Bed Allowed!" The old Beetles song, "When I'm 64" reminds me of my age. But it also reminds me to work hard at play so that I may continue to learn, grow, mature, and resonate with the heart and soul of the ministry of Jesus. Play is the way I do my justice living. Play is the way I preach. Play is the way I visit the hospital bed. There is a way of listening, growing and maturing that will never keep me silent. Play is the way I march on any public issue for policy change. Play is the way I organize with other faithful leaders of the commons. A dear friend and member of Good Shepherd was suffering with terminal cancer. We prayed. We administered the healing ointment of Jesus. We shared stories about the complicated web of medical science. We got the family aligned with significant medial advisers. We discussed the strategic plan needed in confronting his illness. We eventually moved to palliative care. Through it we laughed once hope was regained and the courage could be enjoyed. We embraced death, together, so that life could abide together. {Romans 8}. Recently Rev. Tony Rose and I represented the Good Shepherd congregation at a Faith in New York public meeting on Race. It was at St. Francis Church in Manhattan on January 14, 2016. The session included about 60 persons from four boroughs of our City. They were all persons of faith seeking to regain the justice needed to live in this racially torn city. Four National PICO Staff were there to witness the event. It was a two hour seminar on race relations and the subtleties that that system plays on our subconscious. We laughed. We prayed. We were scared to say the wrong things. We were deeply hurt. We were angry. We were powerfully, wholly, loving. I should also say that it was a massive group of Christians, Muslims, and Jews with various skin tones, cultures, languages, and nations of beginnings (Haiti, Trinidad, British Guyana, India, Mexico, Puerto Rico, Dominican Republic, Norway, Germany, Eastern Europe}. Each of us are the huddled masses and products of "Lady Liberty." For two hours, Rev. Alvin Herring (National PICO Staff for Race Relations and Racial Economic Justice) allowed us to play and climb this massive tree of disparity that is many colored. We climbed and climbed this tree while most of our community says, "No Tree Climbing Allowed!" when it comes to race. Our culture does not want us to talk about it. We even think everything will be alright if everyone just works hard. We do not know the systemic dynamics of that historic disease of America. And that is why we were there climbing together this tree of life. The Commons, the playground, the neighborhood, the very soul of America is at stake. The tree we seek to climb is the racial harmony tree. It is massive. I cannot climb it alone. I will need all those who went to the meeting this past Thursday at St.Francis. But I will need the communities they represent. Faith in New York represents over 70,000 persons of faith in NYC. Good Shepherd is but a small part numerically, but a large part of Faith in New York because of the latter's powerful voice. We have nurtured that voice as theologians and people of the Cross. Faith in New York has committed to climb this dignified tree together. In the Thursday climb we stood together, one to one. We are all shy, embarrassed, and when the Reverend asked us to look into the other's face he was patient because he knew that it is not normal for people trained with a fear-based approach to common life. After some time of learning how to be comfortable in this unusual way of standing in a group learning about race and racism with intimate and revealing stories, we were relieved to announced to one another a Mayan phrase that set the tone for our future play together, our future climb. The phrase is this: "In lak'ech Alak in" It means: "I am you and you are me, or you are another me." A few with African roots remembered this as Ubuntu or: "I AM because WE are!" And many First Nations Peoples of America call this: "Of Many Names." For me, Rabbi Hillel (30 BCE to 10 CE) and Rabbi Jesus of Nazareth (6 BCE to 30CE), came to mind. Each one said: "Love the other in the same way you love yourself." Rabbi Hillel also reminds us about love-justice by saying: "If I am not for myself, who is for me? Yet being only for my self, what am I?" Quite a tree. Quite a climb. So, let me return to the baptismal photo at the top. It reminds me that I presently see a loss of play in the church. And I see this as a potent harm to our children. For some, the Font is meant to be only discretely touched. I disagree. The font needs us to dive in and swim about. The waters need to be churned up ... Played with. I then invite you to remember that kids need to play. They cannot learn without it. Ultimately play develops deep gratitude. It invites courage. We learn courage only by climbing together the trees that are in our common forest. I leave you with the most significant critique of our Children, Youth and Family Ministry. It came from one of our Norwegian students named, "Nest-lovely" in 2012. When discussing the historic Lutheran and Roman Catholic conflict she said, "The difference between Lutherans and Catholics, is that Lutherans have more fun." What a perfect way to build a lovely nest... a strong faith...with an ability to enter this rough and tumble world with courage and joy. I hope and pray you never lose that theology of play at Good Shepherd. Without it you lose the ability to climb. May God bless your play. I remain, Rev. David H. Rommereim [1] The photo below is our high school age, family tree residence.
0 Comments
By Rev. David Rommereim It is hard to talk about race, racism and the institution of racism in all sectors of America. It rears its ugly voice in forms both known and unknown, verbal and silent. As a man raised on the institution of White Privilege I am fully aware that race can only be overcome through building strong relationships across racialized boundaries. I know how hard it is to talk about our institution of race in America. I know there are people who do not want to talk about racism--which tells me there is a serious spiritual dilemma--one that only God's Holy Spirit, God's healing balm of inspiration can heal. Last week, Rev.Tony Rose and I represented the Good Shepherd congregation at a Faith in New York public meeting on Race. It was at St. Francis Church in Manhattan on January 14, 2016. The session comprised about 60 persons from four boroughs of our City--all persons of faith seeking to regain the justice needed to live in our racially torn city. Four National PICO Staff were there to witness this two hour seminar on Race, Relations, and the subtleties that that system plays on our subconscious. We laughed; we prayed; we were scared to say the wrong things; we were deeply hurt; we were angry; and we were powerfully, wholly, loving. I should also say that it was a massive group of Christians, Muslims, and Jews with various skin tones, cultures, languages, and nations of beginnings (Haitian, Trinidadian, Guyanese, Indian, Mexican, Puerto Rican, Dominican, Norwegian, German, and Eastern European). We were the huddled masses and products of "Lady Liberty." For two hours, Rev. Alvin Herring (National PICO Staff member for Race Relations and Racial Economic Justice) allowed us to play and climb the massive tree of disparity that is many colored. We scaled and climbed this tree of racial disparity, even thought most of our community says, "No Tree Climbing Allowed!" when it comes to race. Our culture simply does not want to talk about it. We think everything will be alright if everyone just works hard. We do not know the systemic dynamics of that historic disease in America, particularly when it does not impact us personally, and that is why we were there last week together climbing this tree of life. The Commons, the playground, the neighborhood, the soul of America, and our personal souls are at stake. Last Monday, at another public event the New Bay Ridge gathered on 86th Street and Fort Hamilton Parkway. It was a Rev. Dr. M.L. King, Jr. National Holiday rally in solidarity with our Muslim neighbors in the wake of hate crimes. The action was in response to the woman who was kicked and verbally accosted at that 86th Street Bus Stop because she is Muslim. It was time to take a stand against such un-American behavior. The grassroots community march was a beautiful display of our new multi-colored Bay Ridge. After the march, we convened at Salam Lutheran Church on 80th Street and 4th Avenue for warmth, refreshments, and to hear words of individual voices from the neighborhood, including those of children. Our Children's Chorus of Bay Ridge sang peace songs, and over 300 attendees listened! We are grateful to the local organizers who planned this event. I was honored to participate in the gathering with local residents, and am continuously honored to be part of a larger church community of faith which provides hospitality for these difficult conversations. So, I invite you to read this note (below) from our Presiding Bishop, Elizabeth Eaton. She also calls the church to do the right thing. She invites us to practice the spirituality which takes our voices into public life to stop the barbarity of economic disparity caused by the institution (known and unknown) of race. Pleases note: "In 2013 the median wealth of white American households was 13 times the median wealth of black American households, the widest gap since 1989." (NY Times: 12-31-15, Paul Kiel.) Also, 40% of the collective wealth African Americans was completely lost in the 2008 crash. It has not been recovered. Such statistics say a lot about the words "racialized economic disparity." I remain, Pastor ELCA presiding bishop urges church to have 'difficult conversations' around racism Jan. 20, 2016 CHICAGO (ELCA) - The Rev. Elizabeth A. Eaton, presiding bishop of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), has called on its 3.7 million members to "be the church that models for the rest of this country what it means to have these difficult conversations" about racial inequality. Eaton made her remarks during a Jan. 14 live webcast, "Confronting Racism: A Holy Yearning." Eaton and co-host William B. Horne, a member of St. Paul's Lutheran Church in Clearwater, Fla., presented the one-hour webcast, which addressed the complexities and implications of racism in the context of the criminal justice system. This was the ELCA's second webcast focused on racism. Joining Eaton and Horne for the one-hour conversation were: Judge Yolanda Tanner, an ELCA member who serves as an associate judge for the Baltimore City Circuit Court; Leonard Duncan, an ELCA member and student at Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia; and Charlene Guiliani, an ELCA member and former police sergeant who is a student at Wartburg Theological Seminary in Dubuque, Iowa. During the webcast Duncan, Guiliani and Tanner shared their experiences and careers in the criminal justice system. A portion of the webcast was also dedicated to answering questions submitted via email, Facebook and Twitter. Eaton said that, although the webcast "serves as a way to keep the conversation going, it provides an opportunity for members and congregations to go deeper in our listening and in building relationships. We must commit to looking for ways to continue the conversation in our own congregations and communities." "But it's not going to work if we don't, if you don't, if all of us don't see that we are inextricably bound to each other, and as Paul says, 'When one member suffers, all suffer and when one rejoices, all rejoice.' When we can see that our story is the same and intertwined with everyone else's story, and, more to the point, that it's God story for us, then I think we might see not only the urgency but the beauty and holiness of this moment in time," she said. "Why can't the ELCA be the church that models for the rest of this country what it means to have these difficult conversations?" Eaton asked. "And trusting in our baptism, also believe and understand that we will never be snatched from Christ's hand. I challenge us to do that." The webcast and resources about this church's ongoing racial justice work are available at ELCA.org/webcast. By Rev. David Rommereim This week we, the Lutheran communion, celebrate the Reformation. Four-Hundred-Ninety-Eight Years ago the church was confronted by a reforming priest named, Martin Luther. He wanted the church and her people to become biblically literate. He wanted all people to align with G*d's Salvation History. He knew the established church must never accept payment for forgiveness (indulgences). He knew the teachings of Jesus and the radical nature of the Gospel were at stake in a property rich and fiscally hoarding church hierarchy. We work in and through a church which has borrowed the name of Martin Luther, thus we are called "Lutherans." It is through that name that we have worked with, prayed for, and created healing ministries over the last 498 years. Martin and his colleagues opened the doors of the church. They should never be closed again. At Good Shepherd we continue to insist on being a reforming community of faith. That begins with keeping our doors open both physically and theologically. There are no sacred cows in the church. One of the passages for Sunday's Reformation Worship comes from the poet/prophet Jeremiah. This Sunday one of our newest members, Leo, will read the lessons for the first time in his Chinese inflected English. Leo will read what Jeremiah says in Chapter 31:31: "I [Yahweh) make a new promise with 'the people of faith'. It will not be like the promise that I made with their ancestors. ... But this is the promised covenant I make now. I will put the Torah within them and I will write it on their hearts; and I will be their God, and they shall be my people." Jeremiah had a 40 year career in the destroyed city of Jerusalem. It looked like the South Bronx during the 1970s and 80s. All the wealthy had moved from Jerusalem to Babylon (modern day Iraq). Jeremiah remained and ministered in a city full of poverty. There was no quality education and residents were oppressed by the upper 1% wealthy. Yet, Jeremiah knew in his soul (nephesh) that when speaking through G*d's Name only, doors opened toward hope. During the early 1500s Martin Luther and his colleagues sought to reform the calcified church. It was named "the Reformation." We also borrowed Luther's name to build a church honoring the trajectory of the radical gospel of Jesus known through the study of scripture. We named this church, Luther(an), such as, Good Shepherd Lutheran, Salam Lutheran, Bethlehem Lutheran, Our Savior's Lutheran, etc. Even though Pastor Luther did not want his name used as the name of this church, it stuck. From that tradition we have a responsibility to live with the theology that is continually reforming. We are reformation history. A good example of this reforming effort is seen in the way we worship and teach our children. Our community worship is historic. However, it is best understood as deep time memory that lives in the present hearts and souls of a new emerging congregation. The beauty of Good Shepherd Lutheran church is that we have become a radical hub for diverse expressions of ministry. On any given Sunday, "Some of us believe all the time, some of us believe some of the time, some of us believe none of the time." I am fully aware that each person is seeking to learn, mature, and grow in faith, one day at a time. As a reforming congregation it is also vital to remember that we train students in the faith not to make them robots of the church (such as the older of us grew up with.) We train our children in a church that lives in their world. Kids are not only the future, they are the present! Likewise we are a church with older adults who are near the end of their lives. We are a church that walks with them in these changing times. We hold their hands in prayer. A few of them continue to study scripture weekly with me as they want to keep their minds active and their souls nurtured by the sacred text. I encourage their stories before it is too late. In today's ministry among the Lutheran faithful the fact of climate change is asking us to remember that our historic scripture has been calling us to care for the planet since it was written. But we have been preoccupied with ourselves and forgotten to care for the earth, though in our sacred book, the psalmist continually declares: "The heavens declare the glory of God." What is at stake for Reformation Lutherans today? We can only be theologically pure if and when we take our children's, children's, children's future seriously. We need a theology in a new key. Can we become biblically informed again, as we interact with a reformation that is less pietistic and more eager to reconcile with the people of faith, so that the earth may be restored and maintained with dignity. Ultimately this ministry is not done in Martin Luther's name but rather, in G*d's name. We must learn how to act through that name now more than ever. The world we have offered our children is a world which will demand a new key to thinking about G*d, the church, society, and sacred scripture. The theology of a new key will be based on a reciprocal covenant. G*d has provided a commanding promise (Jeremiah 31:31ff, Romans 5:1, and John 3:16). Now, in 2015, it is time to pay back that covenant with our own reciprocity. Human life on G*d's earth is at stake. Our children need our promise that we will live in the covenant as a model of practicing our faith in a new key with G*d's planet earth as our stewardship. By Rev. David RommereimSimone Weil (1901-1943) "There is a reality outside the world, that is to say, outside space and time, outside man’s mental universe, outside any sphere whatsoever that is accessible to human faculties. Corresponding to this reality, at the center of the human heart, is the longing for an absolute good, a longing which is always there and is never appeased by any object in this world. … Just as the reality of this world is the sole foundation of facts, so that other reality is the sole foundation of good. That reality is the unique source of all the good that can exist in this world: that is to say, all beauty, all truth, all justice, all legitimacy, all order, and all human behavior that is mindful of obligations…. Although it is beyond the ready of any human faculties, man has the power of turning his attention and love towards it. Nothing can ever justify the assumption that any man, whoever he may be, has been deprived of this power. It is a power which is only real in this world in so far as it is exercised. The sole condition for exercising it is consent.… The combination of these two facts~the longing in the depth of the heart for absolute good, and the power, though only latent, of directing attention and love to a reality beyond the world and of receiving good from it~constitutes a link which attaches every man without exception to that other reality. Whoever recognizes that reality recognizes also that link. Because of it, he holds every human being without any exception as something sacred to which he is bound to show respect." (From: “Two Moral Essays” (written as part of her work for the De Gaulle government in exile when Germany occupied France in the early 1940s.) Quoted in Earth Honoring Faith, Dr. Larry Rasmussen, 2013.) Posted above are thoughts from Simone Weil, written in 1942 occupied France. Encountering them one finds out she is writing on behalf of the exiled De Gaulle government during barbaric WWII. She says, There is a reality outside the world, that is today, outside space and time, outside man’s mental universe, outside any sphere whatsoever that is accessible to human faculties. One could dismiss her as a contrarian mystic. You may think she is inviting us into a yearning far beyond scientific reality. Or, she may be what some say, “So heavenly minded and no earthly good.” Listening to her writing some may jump to the conclusion she is speaking of angels, or divine majesty. One may be reminded of the rhetoric of church leaders who told us that God was ‘up there’ looking down on us, and ‘mad-as-hell.’ We are to fear him (always masculine). They told us that God seeks to unveil the mysteries by some fantastic eschatological or apocalyptic event. God will come down to fix the troubled world. We used to call that divine action, end times. Literally the word used for the end is “apocalypse.” It means unveiling. Rather than a television version of apocalypse now in computerized technicolor, we could begin to think of the end as an unveiling, or a revealing of the end of the capacity of divine earth to feed humankind. It could be the end of humankind other than the end of the world as it is. In the ending process humankind has been able to take along thousands of species in some sort of revolutionized premature extinction. The Monarch butterfly is a species I’m rooting for. They are down by 75%. The present “end times” for most species is unveiled in the present catastrophe of 2 to 5 degrees of warming. As Simone writes in the 1940's, she appears to lean into the thoughts that there is a reality outside the world making the humans of this known world restless. Could it be that my personal confidence in this world is jeopardized, therefore I lean toward another realm? Could it be that I am losing control of my known world, its special neighborhood? Could it be that there is a Divine power also restless to return to the original configuration of the created order; beauty, equity, justice, and shalom? Could it be we need to return to a biodegradable and continuously resurrecting biosphere, rather than a world riddled with plastic? Will the unveiling be a violent overthrow of the present regimes? Who will be “left behind?” Or is this simply an anthropocentric model of thinking from a species who plays and pretends to be as important as God? We often think some other power is going to remedy the situation by getting rid of all the bad. It appears, as Simone Weil writes in the early 40's, that the polarization of good and evil often come to the same unveiling through opposing positions. Nazism and its learned Arian model of control sought to remove evil through what turned out to be a personification of evil. Likewise the West sought with the rhetoric of good, to rid evil from the European hemisphere through partnering with evil through the use of armaments all the way to the first use of the atomic threat on two lovely towns in Japan. Today, America has become a nations of mass incarceration. Dr. Iva Carruthers, General Secretary of the Chicago-based Samuel DeWitt Proctor Conference, is a leading voice of the faith community calling for an end to mass incarceration. She calls this a “nation in chains.” Where the U.S. incarcerates more people per capita than any other nation on earth. Getting rid of evil is to 'lock ‘em up and throw away the key.' Today our private prisons have developed a tax based income to the tune of $65,000-$75,000 per year per inmate. It has become profitable to fight evil by chaining persons to long term sentences without rehabilitation. We tend to name that battle with evil as God. That same God we have trusted through a panoply of nicknames (Elohim, Adonai, YHWH, Alla, El, Lord God, etc.). A little less than two millennia ago the community known as the desert fathers lived in isolation and solitude; prayer, contemplation and a new Torah (instruction) focused and Christo-centric faith, working toward building a beloved community. The word they used for sin was not some pejorative moral incursion sentencing you to a life of solitary confinement. It was not a punitive culture (like ours). It did not blame nor shame residents for their wrong-doings. It simply spoke about doing wrong as harming the “beloved community” (Psalm 133). They simply tried to keep from “bad.” That is, bad talk, bad actions, bad. The story of the Desert Fathers is similar to the second story of creation in Genesis (Bere’shit) 2: 4-25. The story of The Garden takes place when Adonai frees Adam (ish) and Eve (ishshah) from the interior of the garden due to their reluctance to maintain the status quo of their responsibilities (Genesis 2.23). Once they broke their promise that they would not eat from the tree of knowledge, in the process of accountability and renewal Adonai (YHWH-God) set them free from the obligation and set them apart to rely on their own ingenuity of connecting with the sublime encounter and the other, the mystery (Genesis 3.1-19). In other words they were “on their own to negotiate the ways and means of living in the abundance of God’s creation. They have to set out on either own, without daddy always making sure all is well. They were in the dangerous realm of responsibility. What they did from here on out was not calculated and sure." They entered the realm of what I call the “ministry, the theology, of "perhaps."” "Perhaps" is when you and I set out on our own. We may find food and water to sustain our family. Perhaps Adonai (God) is with us. But faith refers not to certainty. Faith refers to the great “Perhaps.” You and I believe in the God of Perhaps. The God that insists on our faithfulness and spiritually enlightened behavior. We believe in this God. This God always surprises us with a new encounter with the challenge to faithful living. Yet, perhaps we act like we don’t have faith. So far God has provided for us; every 'jot and tittle.' But, after our mechanistic endeavors for the last 4 to 5 hundred hears of human exploitation and enlightenment, we are not sure. We have sought to eat up the world. Is it because we worry about our comfort? Or, perhaps we actually believe the faith in the holy mystery cannot make us any more comfortable? Air conditioners on a hot day can do that. God can’t. Perhaps, this was their conversation as they entered the fullness of created order. Perhaps “all that is solid melts into air” and we are left with simply and exponentially, our faith. Faith in the God that accompanies and does not control. Faith in the God that breathes into the empty space and does not inhale our mistakes. Ms. Weil goes on to suggest something beyond my own discomfort, or the discomfort caused by the rhetoric of bible thumping preachers. She suggests a deep dive into good. She writes, "The combination of these two facts~the longing in the depth of the heart for absolute good, and the power, though only latent, of directing attention and love to a reality beyond the world and of receiving good from it~constitutes a link which attaches every man without exception to that other reality. Whoever recognizes the reality of the good is engaged with the link." Because of it, she holds every human being without any exception as something sacred to which she is bound to show respect. Needless to say that link provides an inhuman enterprise that calls sacred all that is not human. This the deep dive into good. Through the stories of God expressed through the Semitic peoples 2 to 5 millennia ago, along with those stories of beginnings from many parts of the earth, we hear about the subliminal exchange with the other. Dr. Ulinov calls that the wisdom of the other… or, “other-wise.” Cute but true. Such an exchange with the wisdom of the other is always good. It is always loving. It is always a test of whether the faithful could perfect hospitality with the stranger. Once we acknowledge the fact that humankind has consumed and controlled the earth's fabric of nutritional gravity, we quickly turn to that which is causing the plunge into end times, or the plunge into a limited future. Lately I turn to historic genius to teach me how to live through these circumstances. I see this conundrum of evil and good, through the lens of a 1920 scholar, intellect, and spiritual mystic, W. E. B. Du Bois. He wrote in Darkwater: 'Voices from Within the Veil', published after being censored for 10 years from a frightened academy. The thoughts are printed on the second column on page two of this essay. He says, With Negro and Negroid, East Indian, Chinese, and Japanese they form two-thirds of the population of the world. A belief in humanity is a belief in colored men. If the uplift of mankind must be done by men, then the destinies of this world will rest ultimately in the hands of darker nations. In today’s language we speak of Dark Bodies, Brown Bodies, Yellow Bodies. For my sensibilities, both spiritually and politically, the wisdom of W.E.B Du Bois is clear and resolute. The lives of those who have been kept in a veil through economic exploitation and manipulation are the very lives who will save humankind from this catalytic catastrophe. In my community the little children are noticing that there is talk of a “Race War.” Two have spoken about this specifically in the public conversation of our Sunday Worship. It is a frightening topic. It is highly volatile. And it is a topic that should never be dis-acknowledged by saying to a child, “Oh, don’t worry my child, everything is going to be OK.” Rather, it is worth worrying about. Public life can go good and bad. People of faith always pray and work toward the good. Through the child’s inquiry the adult in the room must discuss and act out the full extent of that it means to be a human being today. We must also acknowledge our human obligations. To be human first means we must be honest about place. The land we borrow to consume. The land we are asked to till and nurture. We are informed through interaction with the full garden (an Eden conscience) that God has shaped. Without that place as a beginning point we will quickly find our pocketbooks making the decision by going shopping. We will then be faced with the decision, ethical and moral decision, of what we purchase or refuse to purchase. This is the most remedial challenge for every consuming American. Each of us must remember that our food travels more than all the jet setters put together. My morning banana has traveled at least 3 K miles to get to my stomach. Love the fact that it is a convenient way to receive the potassium I need from day to day. But I get this 365 days a year. When out of season they come to my breakfast table from farther out. That is a simple banana. Second, we must observe our obligations. What W. E. B. Du Bois reminds us even today is that the whole of the earth is divine, not for those who can pay for it and privatize it. This is our most obligatory mandate for the last century. How we manage the wealth is the survival of life or the extinction of life, as we know it. Without it we all die and the earth remains injured. Sure it will take a long time to remove humankind. And we will take along with us many species in our reckoning. But the damage will be painful and irreconcilable. We will contribute to the demise by sophisticated drone wars and poverty belts subsuming lives and killing folks through hoarding resources. A few have perfected hoarding. Each of us is good at it. So the end of humankind will take some time, but without our obligations we will enhance the process. As a white man, a Christian leader, and a pastor, it is important for me to come to terms with and be clear that I have received benefits Dark Bodies have not. Once I do that I begin to reconcile and place myself before the living God that stands for no nonsense, no bitterness, no deceit. This is the God of truth and we are expected to be free with it. Perhaps even the ‘canoeing in the fog’ photo that my friend, Dr. Arne, took of my son and myself can represent the holy mystery of the great emergence of the recovery of race, nationality and humanity, and the species' among which we live. We may not see beyond the fog but we know we must row into it with confidence. It is at that point we are obligated - when we do the deep dive into the good. I remain, Rev. David H. Rommereim Facing the Dark with a Spiritual FlashlightRev. D. H. RommereimThis photo expresses a narrow, but significant part of the core canon of my theological journey. The literature is part of a library that challenges me to pay attention to the beauty of what the church can and has offered, as well as the trauma caused by the narrow mindedness of the church. The works represented in this photo, assumes that faith implies doubt. What better way than through faith to explore the far reaches of both history and experience. In our post Einsteinian Universe ambiguity and uncertainty are constants. We are no longer able to be precise and objective about any natural or cosmological phenomena. Yet we remain committed to the minute detail of all uncertainty. When we are honest with uncertainty we can imagine a new and healthy partnership with this earth we have borrowed these thousands of years of human spiritual evolution. Ultimately, the photo shows a commitment to an honest engagement with the sacred text and its shalom, In Edinburgh, Scotland, during the first year of the 20th century, the psychologist William James wrote about the Varieties of Religious Experience. He was the Harvard professor of Philosophy and Psychology. His lecture took place at what was called, the Gifford Lectures. It was in 1901. The lecture eventually became the famous book of the same name. It remains important to recognize the accomplishment of William James’ work since it continues to affect the global theology of this 21st Century religious landscape. As we enter the book, William James quickly writes about religion and dogmatism. These are two of the forces that either become, compatible with, or contrarian from one another. Today we have a similar dilemma expressed between religion and spirituality. The common parlance is that one would say, “I am not religious but spiritual.” It categorizes the life force and the ecclesial forms that one aligns with when speaking about faith and the faith community. When one says, “I’m religious” do they mean they are part of an organized faith expression; a church, synagogue, mosque, temple? Or when one says, “I’m spiritual,” do they intend to mean specifically that they are not part of organized religion. Or, are individuals using this dilemma, spiritual versus religious to express what Robert Bellah coined decades ago, “Shielism.” This refers to the individual Sheila who had her own personal faith expressions and expectations apart from anyone else, or any institution. In the early 20th Century the dilemma expressed by William James reminds us that religion and dogma may have been as significant in that era as religion and spirituality have become in our generation’s ecology of faith. To the point of religion and dogma, Dr. James says that, “the theorizing mind tends always to the oversimplification of its materials. This is the root of all that absolutism and one-sided dogmatism by which both philosophy and religion have been infested.” He reminds us that becoming a religious thinker means that there is the possibility of becoming narrow minded rather than far reaching. In my 33 years of pastoral care, it is the oversimplification of materials and the roots of absolutism that have engendered in me the most fear. When a person questions their faith I see it as an opportunity to expand one’s grasp of the mysteries of G*d, rather than a foreboding problem placed in a conundrum of one’s “faith crisis.” I often observed that there appear to be two basic types of faith pilgrimaging: One may use a set of binoculars to see what lies ahead. Another may use a microscope to look for details. Each is method is helpful in the journey, yet of a different orientation and expectation. In this little essay, I see another model useful for the faith journey. I believe it is helpful to face the dark with a spiritual flashlight so as to not be afraid of the unknown, nor of the things that are deeply embedded in the soul that have yet to be clarified. To worry less about the dark, but see that you have batteries for the spiritual flashlight. As an ordained, “set apart,” minister of the Word of God, I see myself as a caregiver of the holy mysteries rather than an adjudicator of the doctrines of the church. It is the grounding principle of my Lutheran hermeneutic that the nurture of faith is the core responsibility of the religious community. If doctrine is able to work its salt so that it marinates the faith properly, then the ministry of the church is good. If doctrine produces unnecessary bitterness in the leadership of the church, then it is not helpful. Pastor Martin Luther would say that if the doctrine does not produce faith then it is adiaphora (secondary). I seek to create an atmosphere in the congregation that honors our questions more than provides answers. I prefer a deliberate, thoughtful response that is not remedial and boarding on empty fussy quicksilver. After all, faith is not certainty. Faith is a manner of living. It is a way of life which includes doubt. However, this is a delicate place from which to lead. Let me give you an example. One of my favorite philosopher/theologians is John D. Caputo. Dr. Caputo is the professor of Religion, Humanities, and Philosophy at Syracuse University. He shares a story about our having different experiences and different names for things as we move in faith through life. He says, “We can lift the lid of a music box and peek inside to see what was hidden from our view, or we can look inside a clock to see what makes it tick, but no matter how hard we try, we can never fully look inside the mind and heart of another person. For the relation with the other is a journey we never complete, the shore we never reach where that incompleteness is not an imperfection but a testimony to the perfect excess of the other; it is not a loss but a source of endless novelty and discovery.” The questions of our faith pilgrimages begin at an early age. Once the Tooth Fairy and Santa Clause become notions of kindness and generosity rather than trustworthy visitors of good fortune, we begin to question the stories. When the child learns that they are part of the parents’ loving-kindness, stress enters the parent/child relationship. At first it is hard to give up Santa because life was simpler and relationships were easy. When the child is ready to accept the fact that the story is a figment of imagination and give up the myth of Santa flying gifts from the North Pole, something deeper and more life-changing occurs and the journey with the sublime that will take a lifetime begins. Parents remember that they too questioned their faith over the years in the remarkable and unremarkable encounters with sublime surprises of pure goodness and love. As the adolescent enters self-differentiated adulthood they enter the world of William James and his variety of religious experiences. Questioning is sine qua non of human living. It is part of our adult life when we engage in the struggle of “making a living.” The world expands along with our questions. When we are getting used to the hard work of adult living (high rent, high food costs, high travel costs, and low wages) we are also engaged with the broadening expanse of our experience. What was once limited to home, school, friendships, acquaintances, now becomes exposed to strangers who may think differently. The world moves from the classroom to the seemingly unlimited expanse of thought, experiences, and opportunities. It is simultaneously exciting and frightening. I remember the words of my Rabbi, Harold Swiss (G*d bless his memory). He reminded me about the phrase “the house of Jacob.” You will read that phrase dozens of times in the Torah, the Psalter, the Prophets, and wisdom literature. “When one hears the phrase, the house of Jacob,” Rabbi would say, “one is asked to honor the questions. After all, it was Jacob (the heel sneak), who became the god-wrestler” (Genesis 32.24-32). G*d is often, and more so now than ever, engaged in wrestling with our 21st Century beleaguered and post-Einsteinian community. As a Bronx pastor I became categorized as a feisty independent Lutheran thinker in what was formerly a Hauge Lutheran tradition. The Hauge tradition of Lutheranism comes from Norway. Why I was in the Bronx perhaps had something to do with the spirit of Hans Nielsen Hauge (but that’s another story). The Hauge tradition was deeply spiritual, less ecclesiastical. It was a reform movement in the Norwegian State Church in the mid 19th century. It traveled to the USA when the Norse began to emigrate en mass during the late 19th and early 20th Centuries. As it came to the USA the reform nature of the movement changed and began to be enmeshed with American puritanism. It became a piety that was individual and morally rigid such that is was so embedded with the individual and the isolated community that it would not organize large ecclesiastical structures. It remained congregational. Yet, its strength was in the ability to transfer questions about G*d into local life; apart from doctrine. If doctrine was to be worthy it would be built upon the personal experience with G*d. Even though Hauge Lutheranism is a distant memory, it has amalgamated into North American religious pragmatism, I am convinced that the spirituality of religious experience is nurtured by the affirmation of independent spirituality. Lutheranism that retains a glimmer of hope in an aged church can only have legitimacy if, and when, it becomes helpful in the building of person and community in a spiritual and religious manner. Our religious evolution may be leaning on the spiritual more than the doctrinal, yet it is that wonderful poet who inspired me to be unafraid, and to maintain a battery for my spiritual flashlight. Wallace Stevens writes, "It was when I said, ‘there is no such thing as the truth,’ that the grapes seemed fatter. The fox ran out of his hole.' " When I visited the neighbors surrounding the Bronx church property, I would ask what they thought about the church. Some would not know it was a church. Many would equate church with a building rather than a gathering of people in the spirit of Christ. I look around in my latest call in Brooklyn and see there are many remnants of church buildings; some have become apartment complexes, others are doing a better job after becoming aligned with Lutheran Health Care, or some other agency of social good. Still others are healthy because they have become engaged with the political issues of the local neighborhood and borough. In ELCA terms that refers to “going public” and partnering with others who seek justice and well-being. I see open-minded leaders as vital in the recovery of the common good. At the same time, I watch as the rise of absolute convictions puts an end to the imagination needed for the dreams of the faith to be healthy and reach the embrace of divine creativity. For Christians and Jews it is the trademark of alignment with the other that points to the integrity of our traditions. For Israel it is Abram’s test shared the book of Bereshit (Beginnings/Genesis). Abraham’s status as a person of faith was lifted high as G*d spoke him to leave home and “Go!” (Genesis 12.1). This is the Lekh Lekha, the travails, of faith offered in Genesis 12-25. He is the hero because he left without knowing the destination. It was a blessing that carved into his soul. His trials were very unsuccessful. Yet it was in Genesis 18.1-15 that we hear about the sacred story that exposes Abram to the radical hospitality necessary for the proper following of divine mystery. How one treats the unannounced stranger in our midst effects how one is faithful to G*d. Again Dr. Caputo writes: "The name of God is the name of trouble. The insistence of God means that God calls for a response or, since God is not somebody who ‘does’ things like call, it means that the calling takes place in the middle voice, in and under the name of God. God calls in the middle voice. The call is perfectly figured in an unexpected and insistent knocking on our door. A disturbing visitation in the night is an uncertainty in which all the sting of ‘perhaps’ is perfectly concentrated, in which the dynamics of ‘perhaps’ and a theology of insistence is both modeled and put in play. Hospitality means to say ‘come’ in response to what is calling, and that may well be trouble. We might say that hospitality is an example of an event, but if so it is an exemplary one, a paradigm, maybe even a surname for any and every event, which can come at any moment, like a wayfarer in need of a cup of cold water unless, perhaps, he is a thief in the night. As an ancient virtue in the Bible, where the very life of the desert traveler depended upon being made welcome, hospitality cuts deeply into the fabric of the biblical name of God, where the invisible face of God is inscribed on the face of the stranger, as if God were looking for shelter. Well beyond its status as a particular virtue, hospitality is a figure of the event, a figure of the chiasm of insistence and existence of call and response.” That he, Abram, fulfills the test of properly responding to the stranger lifts up the fact that the stranger becomes G*d’ self. This is the test which affirms Abram and Sarai ready and able to birth laughter (Isaac) and become the ancestors of G*d’s multinational humanity. What the varieties of religious experience does for the church and its tendency to oversimplify and absolutize its behavior, is to keep it honest. Variety removes us from the threat of absolutism and certainty which has caused so much bloodshed and disquieted behavior with and among those who have a particular choice in their faith practice. It is my vocational goal to lead so that I broaden the spiritual imagination of the person(s) who are attached to the church’s faith journey toward, what I call, communitarian habits of social responsibility (habits of the heart). For biblical persons that is located in the eternal quest for the divine preferential treatment of the poor. And the poor may be expressed as those without a proper pocketbook as well as a proper flashlight. The dearth of imagination in our contemporary, fear-based religion, causes us to be afraid of the deep, dark questions that our religious experience encounters from day to day. Some of the most expanding experiences of faith (as in Wallace Stevens’ poem above), and greatest impacts of a believing community on the person come at what is called, “the night of faith.” or "dark night of the soul." It comes at the dark foreboding moment of question ambiguity and deep thinking that each person, each soul has when expanding their quest for authenticity. When one allows themselves to enter the dark, into what Bereshit calls tohu vabohu (Genesis 1.2), the deep primordial void, one enters the possibility of extinction. Yet the holy mystery, G*d, leaps into the void (tohu vabohu) and decides to remain in the void while light is shed on the dark. I remain dedicated to the wonder and beauty of the ‘spiritual darkness’ as we seek to find the appropriate flashlight to meander through our experience. This “dark night of the soul” is the meditation offered to the Christian community through the poetry of the anonymous. We face this deep spiritual darkness and its adjoining fear not knowing what may come. There is, in other words, no simple glimmer of hope where one can have an escape valve to soften the blow of despair. Therapists know that a point of deep sadness, depression, or fear may become the point at which the client may emerge a new person. This could be the context with Jesus’ contemporary, Nicodemus, in John 3. 1-17. He was the leader of the Jewish community. He came to Jesus at night to speak about spiritual issues. The story is presented as an encounter with two spiritual people. One who seemingly looks at faith through the linear lens; what’s this going to do for me. The other looks at faith through the lens of divine blessing (ruah, spirit, wind breath, Holy Spirit). For believing Christians we, too, have a model for this tohu vabohu (deep darkness). It churns in the form of a story. The story is about a person. That person is represented by the character of Jesus of Nazareth. That story, which Christians call Good News/Gospel, is sweet and gentle hopefulness. It is filled with failure and pain. It is filled with the deep darkness that expresses itself in loss and painful conflict. And it is filled with the promise of a deep abiding presence, soulful presence, if you will, that G*d never leaves us orphans. G*d continues to dive into the dark. This is our spiritual flashlight as we face the unknown. This is a poem about the deep vulnerability of prayer. It is a prayer poem seeking to rest in the correct place with God. It recognizes that my own humanity may, at times, get in the way.
Where Eagles Fly by Rev. David Rommereim Last week God schlepped about The heavens, leaned into earth To inclined Her ear To my prayer. She greeted the nonsense With a twinkle in the eye, Since it cleared not the epidermis, Nor the lymph, keeping its heart Safely tucked from harm. She grieved my melancholy, Knowing it detached all remnant Of the cosmic dust, that accompanies The primordial concillience, Of matter with meaning. Even my flapping tongue Could not reveal the mastery of Her roar and its guiding star. In prayer, I could not shutter, nor quake In the sheer silence of her passing. So, it became a pebble, Skipping across the lake, As if this child could solve The dilemma of being alone. Afterward, I painted my own inquietude Yearning for a new naiveté, That could spin on her whirlwind, Casting to the bay dead words Meant for spring, to discover I could not free my need to know. By David Rommereim
Congratulations! We have turned the corner of a new year! We have celebrated the radical hope of God through the Nativity of our Faith. We have an invitation into a new way of living through the teachings of Jesus the Christ. As a Christian, for me the nativity begins the story of a life nurtured by hope. It is a faith nurtured by the radical hospitality of grace; Such grace is limitless. Then, as a species, we have watched "the ball drop" and a new year begin. Having "the ball drop" is a perfect metaphor for the troubles and the trauma we human persons cause one another. We have a year of racialized tensions all across our land. The question I ask for this new year and new age of a life born of the Nativity is this: Will the hope of Christ challenge us to look at our lives in a new way... a hopeful way. I was deeply honored by our Chinese community, many of whom attended the funeral of slain police officer, Wenjian Liu, in Bensonhurst last Sunday. They went to pray and show support for a tragic moment in our city. I was not honored by the police who turned their back on our Mayor during that service. As a citizen and a Christian it made me feel dirty and deeply sad. I pray our leaders enter this new year able to heal the wounds of this city with dialogue and just laws while, at the same time, leading our way into a new age of racial honesty and secure policing. I make no apologies that, as your pastor, I seek to provide space for public conversation in our neighborhood and city so that we dignify our church ministry and discuss together the challenges which separate us as a people. Healing begins with dialogue. Attempting to heal society without dialogue is akin to going to the doctor when you are sick and telling her, "I'm not going to tell you I'm sick. I'm not going to talk to you." And leaving her to figure it out without you. I remain deeply grateful to the leadership of the Arab American Association as we partnered together for a public conversation on race, racism and national mourning last month. The Soul Cafe was filled with inter-religious people of light who sought to clarify and lead our way into healing as a society, especially when it comes to race and racialized divisions. To be honest, I have noticed that these dialogues are vastly attended by the non-white community. For some reason the white community tends not to show up as much as the Black, Hispanic, Asian. It could be a historic reluctance to talk about difficult subjects. It may be deeper than that. But this is what I observe. As a society we need deep healing which can only begin through that face to face conversation. Throughout my pastoral career I have experienced a hesitance on the part of the white community to talk about race, or, in our present circumstances, about public policing. I have learned to talk about race because of my relationship with African American, Latino, Chinese, and Arab friends. I see no other way to enliven both the grace and hope which guides our way of life than by getting involved and talking. This sort of talk is not easy, but it is healthy and soul affirming. For those of you who have shown up, I am deeply honored to serve you in this way. The dialogue has been a hopeful display of kindness and honesty. Thank you. Now our calendars have changed. This reminds us that we cannot recycle them into the new year. We begin anew. Therefore, I dedicate myself to the Nativity of our Hope and the embrace of Grace which guides this community of faith. Gone Missing, Part 4
The Courage to Stand Against Race-Based Violence by Rev. David Rommereim On December 1, 1955, Rosa Parks, a 42-year-old African American woman who worked as a seamstress, boarded this Montgomery City bus to go home from work. On this bus, on that day, Rosa Parks initiated a new era in the American quest for freedom and equality. She sat near the middle of the bus, just behind the 10 seats reserved for whites. Soon all of the seats in the bus were filled. When a white man entered the bus, the driver (following the standard practice of segregation) insisted that all four blacks sitting just behind the white section give up their seats so that the man could sit there. Mrs. Parks, who was an active member of the local NAACP, quietly refused to give up her seat. Her action was spontaneous and not premeditated, although her previous civil rights involvement and strong sense of justice were obvious influences. "When I made that decision," she said later, "I knew that I had the strength of my ancestors with me." It was a powerful day of reaction and strategic action to racialized behavior in the United States of America. It was initiated by a powerful soulful leader who took a stand against the North American version of Apartheid. We called it, "Jim Crow." Jim Crow laws were set up in America to keep the white species and the African American species separate. It was designed by the power of the white species over against the African American. It is one of the viruses that causes great harm through our land of promise. This African-American civil rights activist was honored by the United States Congress and named "the first lady of civil rights," as well as, "the mother of the freedom." What makes Ms. Parks so pivotal was not that she had just, 'had 'nough.' Or that she 'was just tired' after a long day as a seamstress and didn't want to give up her seat to a white man, in a full Birmingham bus. Rather, her refusing to move was part of a calculated civil disobedience strategy that was prepared for, and acted on, as a faith-based, non-violent, disciplined civil action. She was supported by a long trajectory of leaders trained in this faithful form of democracy. The power of that moment in history (December 1, 1955) inspires and is inspired by its non-violent social critique of "evil political policy." These days all throughout our land people are standing for justice. We live in a violent land. We have learned that every 28 hours a black or brown man or women is killed by the police. That violence must stop for the sake of future generations. I grieve for our kids who grow up in violence, with raw racism, and an environment where there is such a limited ability to listen. After my own three decades of pastoral care in Lutheran congregations in the center city, I long for that same courage of Ms. Parks. I long to dispel the "bad policies" that exasperate our civil shalom. As a Christian, I know that the Lord of the Church has zero tolerance for racial profiling. Over a month ago persons from the Arab American Association of New York met in our Soul Cafe to announce the national campaign, "Take Back Hate." Over the next few days we will be asking our communities to put up a mirror and ask whether we can organize systematically, collectively, and faithfully, so that each of the adults in the room can help the child in the room learn what is good and what is bad ... what is helpful and what is hateful. We begin now as if our lives, our children, and their children depend on our faith active in love. All lives matter! I announce two upcoming meetings - two steps in the marathon we will be running to overcome this systemic evil of our land: "Prayer, Praise, and Peaceful Protest: A Prophetic Response to Violence" Friday, December 12th, 3:30pm, Steps of New York City Hall Organized by the over 70 congregations of Faith in New York and collective allies of justice. We are taking a prophetic stand as faith leaders for healing and justice in our communities. Join us as we gather in solidarity and charge President Barack Obama and Attorney General Eric Holder to fulfill our action plan for ending police violence and bridging the relationship between law enforcement and community. Black Lives Matter. Brown Lives Matter. Our Lives Matter! The rally will conclude with a Jericho Walk and teach-in by 'Black Lives Matter' at a congregation in the City Hall area (TBD) starting at 7pm. "REAL TALK: Where is the Solidarity? From Ferguson to New York" Thursday, December 18th, 6:30pm - 9pm Good Shepherd Church, Soul Cafe Join the Campaign to 'Take on Hate' in New York City for a timely conversation and teach-in on solidarity in light of the recent national spotlight on police reform and racism. We will hear from advocates and experts and engage in exercises that explore our own internal biases and how we can get past them to demonstrate genuine solidarity to oppressed communities. We are ready to engage in a courageous conversation. Are you? We will be joined by leaders from Justice League NYC and Million Hoodies Movement for Justice I remain, Rev. David H. Rommereim Gone Missing, Part 3
To the Public Pain of Ferguson, Staten Island & East New York by Rev. David Rommereim The public violence in Ferguson, Staten Island, Ohio, and now the Pink Houses in East NY is causing a cauldron of fear, anger, bitterness, sadness, and loss. I show my age when the song comes to mind, "When will we ever learn. When will we ever learn." But, as a country, we don't learn. Violence, and particularly racialized violence, takes the lead. When will it end. The ones who are now missing due to the violence at the hands of those hired to protect the peace are Michael Brown (Ferguson, Missouri), Eric Garner (Staten Island), and Akai Gerley (East New York "Pink Houses"). We also know of pregnant women who have been beaten by police - abuse which threatens their birthing. It brings to mind a parish member I served in the Bronx who was gunned down by police in the Castle Hill area. It happened shortly after the Amadou Diallo killing, right around the corner from our church building. Now, in conversations with other pastors and rabbis of our community, the memories become vivid. The lives of our neighborhoods are harmed and threatened by this race based violence. Each name shares specific deep, deep pain. We are a nation at war with other peoples around God's planet. We are also a nation at war with ourselves. Racism runs deep. It must stop. Finding a way to heal from systemic racism is the prophetic call from the core of our faith tradition. Such a calling resounds in passages from sacred texts in both the Hebrew and the Christian Bible. That calling begins with listening to our lamentation. Putting a voice into the lament. Then, only then, we begin to move toward healing. The prophets speak both in Jeremiah 31:15 and Matthew 2:18: "A voice is heard in Ramah, mourning and great weeping, Rachel weeping for her children and refusing to be comforted, because they are no more." Nothing can go any deeper than the lamentation for the children who 'are no more.' People are dying at the hands of the ones we hire to protect our neighborhoods, the ones we ask to protect the peace. That is why the public pain runs deep. It is a pervasive public crisis. On Thursday, I shared in a national call through PICO - our multi-faith, multi-racial, multi-national organization of faith leadership. Faith in New York and PICO shaped the conversation. Leaders began by sharing their pain. Over 60 persons from every region of our country spoke on the call to hear the pain and speak with those from PICO staff, who have been on the ground in Ferguson since the 6th day after Mr. Brown was killed. The meeting was a conference call to pray together, share our pain together, and plan action steps that are deliberate and long term. We know that the community needs healing. We also know that deep systemic action is needed. Thoughtful, deep, profound, and faithful action is needed that is secured by faith in the God of peace. PICO national leaders have met in the White House to demand a national agenda of healing. Our President is in conversation with these faith leaders to begin proposing 5 issues/steps of transformation. The steps are not an answer. Yet, without a systematic effort to heal this systemic evil of racism in our country, we will continue to memorialize the dead, rather than heal the living. Being a white man in a community of privilege, it is my prayer that we join in this grief, share the pain, and know that racism is everyone's thorn in the flesh. By racism I am referring to the systemic dynamic that has kept some on a different trajectory of opportunity. By using that term, racism, I mean to make myself upset, and to upset all of us, so that we may show our faith in the God of peace through the lens of a faith active in love. For me that faith is a Jesus faith. But wherever it comes from, the honorable way to live is to heal the wounds that have killed too many people at the hands of frightened, over zealous police and weapon wielding citizens. Racism is a word with a long history in our land. I have a book on my desk by W.E.B. DuBois who wrote in 1906, that unless and until American deals with its racism, it will never live up to its democratic demands of liberty and freedom. This remains true today. W.E.B. DuBois' voice is resolute. Racism can be overcome when the faith community stands up and speaks through the lens of justice, fairness, hope and healing. This community has a prophetic responsibility to speak through the lens of justice-love. Police policies must be inspired by these values. Without a faithful response, especially from a white community, we will continue with the compartmentalized culture that causes friction and fear; a place to incubate racism. I must be absolutely clear - this is not a quick sprint. It is a marathon of justice-love. I remain, Rev. David H. Rommereim Gone Missing, Part 2
Reflections on the Ministry of Sanctuary and the Pain of Ferguson, Missouri (Photo: Northwestern Cedar) By Rev. David H. Rommereim Last week, I wrote to our 285 persons on the Good Shepherd private e-list a note titled, "Gone Missing." It was a personal testimony about this time of year when we remember persons who have "gone missing" from our Thanksgiving table. It also referred to others missing from the communal hedge seeking to build a strong community of faith. Today, I provide a second e-letter to the 'apostles of sensitiveness' called, "Gone Missing, Part two." My Rabbi always told me, "David, you contribute to the peace of the world when you acknowledge your sources." Well, the source of the term 'apostles of sensitiveness' is from the powerful preacher, theologian, teacher, and Christian mystic, Howard Thurman. His book, "Meditations for Apostles of Sensitiveness" (published in 1948), has remained on my desk for over 20 years. In his illustrative career, he was the pastor of one of the first deliberately multi-racial/multi-national congregations. He wrote weekly devotions as a way of garnering conversation and support for a very challenging mission. Today, I write while the turkey cooks. It is a bittersweet Thanksgiving. It is a day, which provides what the Celts call "thin places." That is, the thin line which intersects the sacred and profane. It is where joy and sorrow, laughter and tears, beauty and ugly, touch each other. Today is sweet because I am with my beloved family and thinking of wonderful friends. It is sweet because I respectfully think of the ministry at Good Shepherd. I am honored that you support an inclusive approach to the radical hospitality taught by that itinerant poet, prophet, healer, economic agitator, and storyteller, Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ of God. Good Shepherd is a ministry of hospitality that goes well beyond setting a good table or a nice coffee hour after worship. The power of hospitality takes place in many ways, but yesterday the ministry of hospitality was clarified once again. On the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, a few of us spent the morning at Immigration and Custom's Enforcement (ICE). We accompanied Joe and Mei to their immigration "check in." Each of us knew the quiet pain resting on each face of the four rows of migrants also "checking in" on the 9th Floor of the Federal Plaza just above City Hall and Wall Street. In that 33 x 25 sitting room, there is always a silent 'shout out' to the intimidating fear due to the record number of deportations over the tenure of the Obama administration. We have been going there ever since we helped found the NY New Sanctuary Coalition seven years ago. With the latest "Executive Order" announced last week by our President, we know that many may be given temporary safety from the threat of deportation. Joe and Mei may be one of the families spared through this order. Yet, there remain a vast number of immigrants not affected by the president's Executive Order. In addition, a hostile opposition has retaliated by every means possible to 'send 'em back to where they came from,' by every means necessary. Despite the political hostility, Good Shepherd ministry of hospitality remains committed to being vigilant until we Americans live up to the tradition of welcoming the stranger. Not a day passes without my seeing that icon of liberty in our New York harbor. She reminds me of that American value - of welcome. At the "check in" everyone knows the administration has placed a quota for deportation. You just never know if this is your day to help fill the quota. Each person, each family, knows that "today may be your day." Because of that fear based ecology, each person sits quietly despite a loud television blaring Fox News in the upper corners. Some pray, others just sit and wait to be called forward. There are a few immigration lawyers. Most are alone. We address the ministry of accompaniment because, as people of faith, sanctuary is the spiritual power of our tradition. We practice sanctuary every Sunday while you visit to worship in public. Hospitality, together with sanctuary, fulfills our covenant with God. "Do unto others what you would have them do unto you." Our team accompanying Joe and Mei feel very helpless. However, we remain called to be there and provide sanctuary in this hostile universe. It is a ministry of presence. As it turns out, I was able to go with Joe and Mei to speak with the ICE officer inside a little room. Rarely do you get a chance to accompany that far. The four of us spoke. He was fully aware that there were seven persons accompanying this family. There was limited conversation. He did almost all the talking. I got a few words in to remind the officer that this family is needed among us. We went home relieved. All is well for a little longer. Joe and Mei will have a quiet Thanksgiving. It was John Berger who wrote in the lovely book, Hold Everything Dear (Pantheon Books, 2007), "The world has changed. Information is being communicated differently. Misinformation is developing its techniques. On a world scale emigration has become the principle means of survival." Today's Thanksgiving celebration bumps into the Celtic "thin places" sharing the bitter with the sweet. It brushes the principle means of survival to gather where you are needed and where you may be able to provide help. Migrants do that consistently throughout our land and history as a nation. The experience at Federal Plaza leaves a bitter taste because we watch our political hired help (all elected officials) make justice seem less value driven, less constitutionally inspired, and more like a number and a name on their accountants' financial ledger books. We have become a country where our democratic values of justice and fairness appear to have "gone missing." That political stalemate is also vivid today as the painful and historic events in Ferguson, Missouri blare across our land. You can see the sad and bitter taste in the outrage and cold anger of those who have directly experienced justice deferred. I can see it even in the fear of the photographed eyes of those who are hired to "preserve the domestic tranquility and provide for the common defense and the promotion of the general welfare" (as each of us memorized in 6th Grade civics class). Despite their military armament, the police seem to act out of fear, rather than the professionalism and respect we trained them to provide. The mass of desperate people are armed with anger, disappointment, and deep pain located in the living memory of the one who has gone missing since August, Michael Brown. It was the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. who preached these words on March 14, 1968: "As long as justice is postponed we always stand on the verge of these darker nights of social disruption." He spoke those words three weeks before he was assassinated. Those prayerful words have come alive again this week after the historic decision in Ferguson, Missouri. Their Robert MacCulloch, Saint Louis County prosecuting attorney, announced that no criminal charges would be filed against Darren Wilson, the police officer who killed Michael. Today, we are invited to remember justice gone missing. It has been deferred for a vital part of our American heritage; often those less fortunate, or on the other side of opportunity. I cannot face this day of wonderful joy without touching the fearful pain and praying over the vital memory that has kept me alive these 63 years. As a white man, I have a significant opportunity. I grew up with easier access to opportunity than the African American, the Latino, the people of color, and women. I am one of those who has benefited by our racialized system that supported me. Justice is not deferred, for people like me. Yet, because of Ferguson and places like Staten Island or other parts of Brooklyn, we see the suffering from wanton injustice spewed from the guns of those we hire to insure the "domestic tranquility." I have always understood justice and its kindred spirit, fairness, to be available to me. I have lived a privileged life. Yet, now, the news from Ferguson, Mo, and other cities from around this country, we see a justice deferred that has injured the very soul of our country. The captions in many articles I have listened to remind me that when justice is deferred violence erupts. Moreover, violence is not in the will of the people. Violence rises in that thin space between anger and silence. Violence enters the scene when people are unheard. I look at the photos and see young persons of color, together with a few white folks, trying to undo the harm and to practice fairness. Nevertheless, the faces of these youth leave me with a sigh too deep for words. As a person of faith and a citizen I know that one of the diseases we witness is the virus called amnesia. When amnesia goes viral in the church, we forget who we are and why we gather for the ministry of "faith, hope, and love" (1 Corinthians 13). When amnesia goes viral in citizens, we forget who we are. We forget our founding principles that state, "we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." We forget that we are designed, as a country, to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity. These values and the covenant between people of faith and the Trinitarian God of justice, God of mercy, and God of fairness, are the rock of our living. In our fragile politicized, polarized, and compartmentalized culture it is essential... no, it is vital (the Élan vital - life giving), that we cling to this granite which houses the permanence of our values for ourselves, our posterity, and all residents on this divine planet. For now, however, please enjoy the gift of Thanksgiving and allow the photo at the beginning of this Thanksgiving muse provide a moment of profound memory that will accompany you in thin places; like this tree clinging to granite. It is amazing that something as strong as this northwestern Cedar could stand so tall and so confident only because she clings to that rock which has given her life. I remain, Rev. David H. Rommereim |
Shepherd's
|
The Lutheran Church of the Good Shepherd
7420 Fourth Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11209 www.goodshepherdbayridge.org 718-745-8520 |
© COPYRIGHT 2021. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
|